The Collective Art of Unreasonable Hospitality

How Will Guidara transformed fine dining through radical collaboration

Image by Studio Superaarde with Midjourney

A bland night out

In 2006, Eleven Madison Park in New York City had all the ingredients of a world-class restaurant: prime location, an acclaimed chef, and an ambitious young general manager. But despite its Michelin-starred reputation, the restaurant lacked soul. Guests came for the food, not for the experience, which was stiff, transactional, and predictable.

General manager Will Guidara believed that the restaurant could become something much more than just a renowned fine dining establishment. He believed in the possibility of a dining experience filled with magic, surprise, and deep connection. But, in an industry obsessed with precision, control, and execution, how do you foster genuine human connection?

Hospitality as a collective act

Guidara always believed that hospitality was more than just good service—it was about making guests feel seen. But transforming an entire restaurant culture would require a radical departure from conventional fine-dining norms. Instead of focusing solely on the mechanics of flawless execution, he decided to prioritize something deeper: unreasonable hospitality.

At Eleven Madison Park, Guidara transformed hospitality into an ecosystem. Every interaction mattered, from the suppliers who delivered exceptional ingredients, to the kitchen team that transformed them into art, to the front-of-house staff who transformed meals into moments through deep listening and intuition. Even guests became co-creators, shaping their own experiences. By aligning everyone in the value chain around generosity and creativity, Guidara redefined what it meant to create unforgettable experiences—together.

Give them a hot dog (How romantic!)

One evening, a couple celebrating their 50th anniversary was midway through their 10-course meal when the wife turned to her husband and said, “Do you remember our first date? You bought me a hot dog in Madison Square Park. It was all we could afford.” A passing waiter overheard the exchange and immediately brought it to the kitchen. The team understood: this wasn’t just nostalgia—it was an opportunity. Instead of the planned sixth course, the couple was served a New York City hot dog, wrapped in paper, just like on their first date.

In that moment, the restaurant wasn’t just serving food—it was engaging in a shared act of creation. The rigid lines between chef and guest, between service and experience, evaporated. What started as a casual remark became an experience, not just because the restaurant responded, but because they invited the guest into the process. Eleven Madison Park wasn’t just meeting expectations anymore—it was shaping memories.

Radical collaboration for transformational results

Hospitality at this level doesn’t just happen. Guidara empowered his team to see themselves not simply as service staff but as co-creators of an extraordinary experience. He emphasized three key principles:

  • Trust and psychological safety: Guidara created a culture where employees felt free to take risks. They didn’t have to check with managers for every decision—if an opportunity arose to delight a guest, they had permission to seize it.
  • Hyper-awareness: Staff were trained to notice the small details that could lead to magical moments. A passing comment, a nostalgic memory, or even a subtle body language shift could be the key to an unforgettable experience.
  • Collaboration without ego: In a high-stakes restaurant environment, hierarchy is rigid. But for hospitality to feel seamless, kitchen staff, servers, and managers had to work as one. This required stepping out of silos and fostering open communication.

The impact of this approach was staggering. Under Guidara’s leadership, Eleven Madison Park skyrocketed from a respected fine-dining establishment to the #1 restaurant in the world in 2017, according to the World’s 50 Best Restaurants. Employee engagement increased, guests returned again and again, and the restaurant’s revenue and reputation soared. The transformation wasn’t just about better food—it was about a deeper and more connected dining experience.

Read more in Will Guidara's book Unreasonable Hospitality.

This Inspiration Story is filed under:
Business

Get your innovation score

In just 2 minutes, answer 16 questions and unlock a roadmap that clarifies your innovation approach, strengthens execution, and aligns your team.

Explore other relevant Stories

Beyond the Horizon
How Amelia Earhart’s solo flight launched a movement
The Radiant Pioneer
How Marie Curie’s quest for knowledge changed the face of science
The Relentless Pursuit of Craftsmanship
The Steve Jobs blueprint for innovation
The Power of the Skateboard Mindset
How Spotify revolutionized agile product development
Powers of Ten: Scaling Perspectives
How Charles and Ray Eames used design to reframe systems thinking
Living Systems Design Ahead of Its Time
The Erie Railroad Company’s groundbreaking organizational chart
Solving the Puzzle of Sustainable Enterprise
How Ray Anderson pieced together a revolutionary approach to business
Reimagining Architecture Through Nature
How Frank Lloyd Wright’s Fallingwater challenged the limits of form and function
When Poetry Takes Flight
How David Whyte reframed engineering culture through verse
The Transformation of a Plastic-Obsessed Industry
How Brianne West leveraged her customers to launch a global zero-waste beauty brand
The Zen of Collaboration
How Phil Jackson fostered trust and unity to build a basketball dynasty
Check Your Ego at the Door
How Quincy Jones orchestrated a musical movement for change
Peak Performance
How Patagonia redefined corporate responsibility and environmental stewardship
Enshrining Rights of Nature
How Ecuador took nature protection to a whole new level
The Art of Living Landscapes
How Piet Oudolf redefined gardening through nature-inspired design
Nurturing Minds, Shaping Futures
How Maria Montessori’s curiosity and innovation redefined learning
A Convener of Compassion and Dialogue
How the Dalai Lama bridged divides with wisdom and presence
Unveiling the Invisible Enemy
How John Snow's systemic thinking transformed public health
Reaching for the Stars
How NASA’s vision and teamwork propelled humanity beyond Earth
Beneath the Waves
How Jacques Cousteau's visionary leadership built a generation of ocean advocates